AOL News has a new home! The Huffington Post.

Click here to visit the new home of AOL News!

Hot on HuffPost:

See More Stories
Opinion

Opinion: It Must Be Al Gore's Fault

Sep 1, 2010 – 7:54 PM
Text Size
John Merline

John Merline Opinion Editor

(Sept. 1) -- When news reports surfaced that James J. Lee -- the now-dead Discovery network hostage-taking suspect -- had apparently written a rambling, repetitive and just plain crazy manifesto, it wasn't much of a stretch to predict that someone would try to draw a connection between his actions and environmentalists. Or is it anti-immigration groups?

After all, his screed demanded that Discovery show its "commitment to save the planet" by, among other things, dropping shows that encourage "the birth of any more parasitic human infants."

"Humans are the most destructive, filthy, pollutive creatures around and are wrecking what's left of the planet with their false morals and breeding culture," the manifesto states.

Hey, haven't some environmentalists warned in the past that overpopulation fosters global warming? And didn't Lee himself say he experienced an "awakening" when watching Al Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth"?

Lee's tract also called for strict immigration controls, leading Think Progress' Andrea Nill to warn ominously that it "bears troubling resemblance to views and policies espoused by anti-immigration groups."

Seriously?

It's an unfortunate reflex these days among pundits and politicians trying to score cheap political points against their ideological opponents. Just find the thinnest thread to tie them to the actions of some deranged nut job who happens to espouse somewhat similar views. See how dangerous and extremist their positions are?

So, liberal talk show host Keith Olbermann once blamed competing talk show host Bill O'Reilly for the murder of abortion doctor George Tiller.

Sponsored Links
Conservatives once tried to draw parallels between the Unabomber and Gore.

President Bill Clinton attempted to connect the horrible Oklahoma City bombing to the rhetoric coming from right-wing talk shows.

It's all bad logic of the reductio ad absurdum variety. And we'd all be better off if everyone took this opportunity to forever swear off this pathetic rhetorical device.

Yeah, I know. That's just crazy talk.
Filed under: Opinion
Follow us on Facebook and Twitter.


2011 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Featured Comments

52 comments

  • If it had been a far right-wing person who was the hostage-taker today, there would have been a FIRESTORM of media angst about the "Tea Bagger lunatics" and how they are going to kill everyone in America...and Obama would have made a speech! Now that it's known that he was a far-LEFT person, the media is noticably restrained. Don't people see this incredible double-political-standard that today's media applies to the news?

    themaskctf

    Thu Sep 02 02:00:46 EDT 2010

  • Great article!! You nailed it. Finger pointing with the thinnest of reason is practiced by both sides. Just the fact that I can say "both sides" should tell us all something. Aren't there many more opinions than just two in this great country? And why do these partys have a difference of opinion if they are both reading the same Constitution? Obviously someone is making it a lot harder and more confusing than it has to be just to keep us off balance and confused. I am not confused anymore at all. If you are an encumbant, out you go this cycle. If we are the greatest country in the world then why are we in this mess? Both partys got us here obviously.

    Changling

    Thu Sep 02 05:14:56 EDT 2010

  • Naww, it's always George W. Bush's fault. Anyone who's ever based their politics on a bumpersticker knows that! And that pesky secondary smoke. Why it's better that a convicted non-smoking child molester be welcome in a bar, than anyone with a lit cigarette. These are truths set in stone, and I DO mean Oliver!

    irvinghotshot

    Thu Sep 02 05:44:42 EDT 2010

Add your comment

ON FACEBOOK