U.S. District Judge John Antoon sided with the Sons of Confederate Veterans, ruling that a state law allowing the legislature to approve specialty plates violates the group's First Amendment right to free speech.
The Florida branch of the Sons of Confederate Veterans sued the state after its 2008 application to approve a "confederate heritage" plate was denied by the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles and then permanently stalled in the state legislature.
The license plate features the Confederate flag, coat buttons worn by Florida's Confederate soldiers and the phrase "Confederate heritage." The group had raised the required $60,000 application fee and collected the signatures of more than 30,000 Florida residents who said they might be interested in buying such a license plate.
Florida Sons of Confederate Veterans Commander Douglas Dawson praised the judge's decision and said the application process was clearly unfair. "It was viewpoint discrimination," Dawson told AOL News in a phone interview today.
Antoon agreed, calling the process "unconstitutional to the extent it grants the Florida Legislature discretion to decline approval of an application for a specialty license plate based on the sponsor's viewpoint," according to the Orlando Sentinel.
His decision paves the way for the Sons of Confederate Veterans to reapply for the plate. Not that the group will reveal its game plan. "There ain't no general that's gonna share his battle plan. And I ain't talkin'," Dawson said, echoing similar statements he's made in the past.

The Mortgage Mess: Just How Many Screwups Were There?





